Building Communities of Both Sorrow and Joy: How Lament Transforms Fellowship
Click on the image to PRE-ORDER Kingdom Revolution (eBook) from Amazon for $0.99 today!!
When Everything Falls Apart: A Biblical Guide to Hope Through Lamentations
Sunday morning. You slide into your usual pew carrying an invisible load: Dad’s Alzheimer’s diagnosis, your teenager’s college acceptance, your friend’s sudden job loss. Around you, others carry their own hidden stories—anniversary celebrations, eviction notices, pregnancy announcements, and cancer reports.
The worship leader invites everyone to “come with joy and thanksgiving.” You wonder: What do you do when your heart holds both gratitude and grief? How do you sing “Blessed Be Your Name” when half of you wants to shout “Hallelujah!” and the other half wants to whisper “Help me”?
This moment captures exactly why most churches struggle to foster genuine community. We’ve never learned how to hold both sorrow and joy at the same time.
Over the past three weeks, we’ve discovered that God gives permission to fall apart (Part 1), sometimes orchestrates our breaking (Part 2), and grows hope within suffering (Part 3). But here’s what we haven’t addressed: this journey doesn’t happen alone.
Biblical lament is designed for community.
Here’s the final piece: Biblical lament doesn’t just transform how we relate to God—it also transforms how we relate to one another. It teaches us to build communities grown-up enough to hold both tears and laughter, both celebration and mourning, and both the feast and the fast.
ORDER MY NEW BOOK TODAY FOR $9.99 (eBook)
The Problem with Everyone Feeling the Same Way
Most churches operate with what I call “emotional matching”—the assumption that everyone should feel roughly the same way at the same time. But real community creates space for the full range of human emotions to coexist.
Think about how your church structures its gatherings: Victory Sundays celebrating testimonies, Breakthrough conferences focused on claiming promises, and Blessing services emphasizing gratitude. These aren’t wrong, but when they become the only approach, they accidentally pressure people toward emotional conformity.
Consider your own experience:
What if you’re in the valley during Victory Sunday?
What if promises feel hidden during a Breakthrough conference?
What if you’re learning to say “great is thy faithfulness” from the bottom of a pit during a Blessing service?
People learn to stuff their real struggles to match the expected congregational mood. We end up with churches full of people wearing masks—not because they want to be fake, but because they don’t know how to be authentically struggling in a community that primarily knows how to celebrate.
The result? Happy people feel guilty. Hurting people feel alone. Both groups feel isolated, and authentic community becomes impossible.
What Lamentations Shows Us About Real Community
So what would real community look like instead? Here’s what’s surprising: Lamentations—that book of grief and sorrow—gives us the blueprint.
Here’s what’s beautiful about Lamentations: it shows us exactly how this works. Watch how chapter 5 moves from “I” language to “we” language:
“Remember, Lord, what has happened to us; look, and see our disgrace” (Lamentations 5:1-2).
Your personal grief doesn’t happen in isolation—it affects everyone around you, and their health affects your healing.
But here’s what’s brilliant: Lamentations never demands that everyone be in the same emotional space. Instead, it creates vocabulary and rhythm that lets the community hold multiple experiences at once.
Some are remembering recent loss, while others are remembering God’s faithfulness. Some are crying out in fresh pain while others are learning to hope again. The book doesn’t try to sync everyone’s emotions—it creates space for the full spectrum of human experience before God.
Remember from Part 1 how God gives permission to fall apart? That permission extends to community. In Part 2, we saw that sometimes God orchestrates our breaking—meaning some people are experiencing God-allowed difficulty. In Part 3, we discovered hope that grows within suffering—meaning some are learning to hope from the bottom, while others celebrate obvious blessings.
This is what grown-up faith community looks like: not everyone feeling the same way, but everyone being real about how they actually feel.
The Difference Between “Fix-It” Churches and “Sit-With” Churches
Most of us have experienced both types of communities:
Fix-It Churches start with one assumption: problems exist to be solved quickly. Someone shares a struggle? Immediately, out comes the advice, Bible verses, prayers for breakthrough, and counseling referrals. The goal? Get people from problem to solution. Fast.
Sit-With Churches understand that some suffering can’t be fixed quickly and some questions don’t have easy answers. They’ve learned the sacred art of presence—being with people in their pain without needing to eliminate it.
Jesus himself modeled this approach. When he encountered the sisters grieving Lazarus, he didn’t immediately fix the problem or offer theological explanations. First, “Jesus wept” (John 11:35)—he entered their emotional space before acting.
I learned this the hard way—through years of well-intentioned damage. Early in ministry, I responded to every shared struggle with advice and Bible verses. I thought I was being helpful. Instead, I was communicating that people’s authentic emotions needed to be fixed rather than heard.
Consider these different responses to someone sharing about ongoing depression:
Fix-It Response: “Have you tried [specific solution]? Let me pray that God breaks this depression off your life. Here’s a book that might help.”
Sit-With Response: “Thank you for trusting us with this. It takes courage to name depression, especially in church. This sounds incredibly difficult. How can we support you in this season?”
The fix-it response leaves people feeling rushed or misunderstood. The sit-with response acknowledges courage, validates experience, and asks how to love well rather than assuming what’s needed.
Creating Space for Both Feast and Famine
Okay, so this sounds good in theory. But how does it actually work? How do you celebrate your promotion when your small group leader just lost his job?
Real community doesn’t pretend everyone’s happy at the same time. Instead, it creates space for people in different seasons: some celebrating, some grieving, some just trying to survive.
If you could only implement three changes to create more authentic community, start here:
Change 1: Restructure How You Pray Together
Instead of the typical “How can we pray for you?” question that often generates only problems to be solved, try questions that acknowledge the full spectrum of experience:
“How have you seen God’s character this week, whether in joy or difficulty?”
“What’s one thing you’re celebrating and one thing you’re struggling with?”
“Where do you need the community to rejoice with you, and where do you need us to weep with you?”
Change 2: Train People in the Ministry of Presence
Maybe you’re thinking, “I’m not a pastor. How does this apply to me?” Here’s the thing: these skills work whether you’re leading a church or just trying to be a better friend:
Learn the difference between sympathy and empathy. Sympathy says, “I feel sorry for you.” Empathy says, “I feel with you.” Empathy doesn’t require having had the same experience; it requires the willingness to enter another’s emotional space without needing to change it.
Understand that not every hard moment requires words. Sometimes the most Christ-like response is simply showing up and staying present. The ministry of presence doesn’t always need theology or advice—sometimes it just needs proximity.
Model emotional honesty. People who can acknowledge their own struggles create permission for others to be authentic about their own struggles. When I began sharing my own seasons of doubt and difficulty from the pulpit, our church became a safer place for others to do the same.
Change 3: Create Church Rhythms That Honor All Seasons
Instead of making every Sunday feel the same, create intentional rhythms that acknowledge different aspects of faith:
First Sunday: Celebration and testimony service
Second Sunday: Teaching focused on growth through difficulty
Third Sunday: Prayer that includes both thanksgiving and lament
Fourth Sunday: Communion and reflection on God’s faithfulness in all circumstances
Create regular opportunities for both community celebration and community grief. During Advent, acknowledge that some are waiting expectantly while others are grieving losses. During Easter, celebrate the resurrection while making space for those who are still in the tomb.
The Art of Celebrating While Others Grieve
One of the trickiest parts of real community? Learning to celebrate authentically while others are grieving deeply. This isn’t about suppressing joy—it’s about expressing joy in ways that create space for grief rather than trampling it.
Celebrate with humility. Acknowledge that your current joy is a gift, not a guarantee. This doesn’t diminish gratitude—it keeps it grounded in reality.
Include the grieving when appropriate. Sometimes the best way to honor people under challenging seasons is to invite them into your joy. But always ask rather than assume: “I know this is a hard season. Would it be helpful or painful to join us for the celebration dinner?”
Express gratitude without implying formulas. Instead of “God is so good [to me],” try “I’m grateful for this unexpected gift in a world where good things don’t always happen when we want them.”
Remember that your joy can encourage others. People in difficult seasons often find hope by witnessing God’s faithfulness in others’ lives, even when they can’t sense it in their own.
The Art of Grieving While Others Celebrate
Learning to process grief authentically while others experience joy requires wisdom and courage.
Don’t feel pressure to match the room’s energy. Authentic community means you can be honestly sad while others are genuinely happy. This isn’t selfishness—it’s integrity. Remember from Part 3 that hope doesn’t require you to feel optimistic—it rests on God’s character regardless of your emotional state.
Find ways to honor others’ joy from your place of sorrow. You can genuinely celebrate with others without pretending to be in the same emotional space. “I’m so happy for you, even though this is a difficult season for me” is perfectly honest and loving.
Seek out safe people who can hold your grief without trying to fix it. Every community should have people trained in the ministry of presence.
Remember that your grief can serve others. When you model authentic processing of loss, you give others permission to be honest about their own struggles.
When the Community Itself Needs to Lament
Sometimes, entire communities face collective grief—the sudden death of a beloved pastor, scandal, loss of a building, or economic hardship affecting multiple families.
Lamentations teaches us that communities, like individuals, need space for grieving together. When churches rush past collective trauma, they drive grief underground where it surfaces in unhealthy ways later.
Acknowledge collective loss honestly. Don’t minimize community-wide pain or rush toward “looking on the bright side.” Remember from Part 2 that sometimes God himself orchestrates breaking—even in communities.
Create ritual around collective loss. Mark endings, honor what’s been lost, create sacred space for community mourning. Hold memorial services not just for people but for dreams, ministries, or seasons that have ended.
Resist the pressure to recover quickly. Healing happens on God’s timeline. Some community wounds require extended time to heal properly.
The Hope That Emerges from Authentic Community
When churches learn to hold both sorrow and joy, something beautiful happens: hope emerges that’s both deeper and more sustainable than hope built on perpetual positivity.
People discover they can trust a community that doesn’t require them to be emotionally perfect. They learn they can be authentic about struggle without fear of judgment.
But they also discover they can trust joy that’s been tested by sorrow. Celebration that emerges from a community that also knows how to grieve has a depth that superficial positivity can’t match.
This is the hope Lamentations points toward—not hope that eliminates difficulty, but hope that coexists with difficulty. Not hope that promises easy answers, but hope that remains faithful when answers are scarce.
Instead of living FOR hope (waiting for things to get better so we can finally be okay), we learn to live FROM hope (drawing strength from God’s faithfulness regardless of circumstances).
Building Your Own Community of Lament and Praise
Whether you’re a pastor, small group leader, or simply someone who wants to contribute to healthier community, here are practical steps:
Start with yourself. Model emotional honesty. Share both joys and struggles authentically. Let people see how you process difficulty without trying to sync your emotions with others.
Learn to ask better questions. Instead of “How are you?” try “How is your heart today?” Instead of “What can we pray about?” try “Where do you need God’s presence this week?”
Practice the ministry of presence. Sit with people in pain without trying to fix them. Celebrate with people in joy without needing to relate it to your own experience.
Create space for multiple emotional experiences. In conversations, prayer times, and gatherings, acknowledge that people are in different seasons.
Be patient with the process. Building communities that can hold both sorrow and joy takes time. People hurt by emotionally immature churches need time to learn that authenticity is safe.
The Community That Changed Everything
Imagine walking into a church where you can be honest about depression without being subjected to spiritual formulas. Where you can celebrate your promotion without feeling guilty that others are struggling. Where you can grieve your miscarriage without pressure to “move forward” on anyone else’s timeline.
Picture small groups where people share both gratitude and grief, where prayer includes both thanksgiving and lament, and where the goal isn’t everyone feeling the same way but everyone being real.
This isn’t fantasy—it’s the kind of community that biblical lament creates when we take it seriously. It’s what happens when we stop trying to sync everyone’s emotions and start creating space for the full spectrum of human experience before God.
The four-week journey through Lamentations isn’t just about understanding an often overlooked Bible book—it’s about learning to build communities worthy of the gospel. Communities that can hold both the cross and the resurrection, both the valley and the mountaintop, and both the darkness and the dawn.
Your community might be a church of five hundred or a small group of eight. Wherever God has placed you with other believers, you have the opportunity to help create space for both lament and praise, both sorrow and joy.
The world is watching to see if our communities can hold the full complexity of human experience with the grace and truth that Jesus demonstrated. They’re looking for churches that can weep with those who weep AND rejoice with those who rejoice—simultaneously, authentically, without demanding that everyone be in the same emotional space.
Lamentations teaches us that God can handle our authentic emotions—all of them, in any combination, in any season. The communities that learn this lesson become refuges for broken hearts and launching pads for renewed hope. They become places where people can fall apart safely and be put back together slowly, where celebration has depth because it coexists with honest grief, where hope is unshakeable because it’s been tested by reality.
Your Jerusalem may have fallen, but you don’t have to rebuild alone. When God raises up something new from the ruins, your community will be ready to hold both the grief over what was lost and the joy over what’s being born.
This concludes our four-part journey through the Book of Lamentations. Thank you for walking through the darkness toward the dawn, for learning that falling apart can be faithful, and for discovering that hope grows best in the soil of honest grief. May your communities become places where every season of the soul can find a home.
——
FYI: Some of the links above are affiliate links. If you choose to purchase items linked, I will receive a small commission from that sale.
If you find this blog helpful and want to say thanks, click here to buy Danny Davis a coffee.
